Ed
I never was too much into the personification of Ana (or Mia, depending on your personal food kink/disorder type).
But I’ve seen a few people in recovery jokingly speak of Ed (E.D. – Eating Disorders), as a non-glamourized personification.
And I was thinking about this other day and it occurred to me, living with Ed is so much like living with an abusive man.
You don’t want anyone to know Ed is hurting you. So you hide the harm Ed does. Ed leaves you bruises and you joke about how clumsy you are. But Ed is hurting you. His physical abuse leaves you bruised, tired, sore. Your very bones ache. You feel nauseated and sick. Sometimes he knocks out your teeth. Sometimes he cuts you. You wear long pants and long sleeved shirts in the summer and say you’re cold (which is true, because he denies you enough food with iron in it to stay warm). Sometimes Ed hurts you so badly you end up in the emergency room.
He controls everything you do, deliberately isolates you from your friends so you can spend more time with him, criticizes you constantly, picks on your clothes, your looks, your makeup, relentlessly points out every flaw. If you gain even one single pound he notices, and bullies you until you do something to take it off, and five more. Ed points out other women and tells you they are prettier, thinner, more desirable. Ed points out other joggers or bikers who go faster than you, even after you’ve been going for miles, and tells you that you’re lazy if you can’t keep up.
Ed keeps you from sleeping at night, bothering you, keeping you up late, reminding you of every mistake you’ve made that day, sometimes yelling at you until you get out of bed and promise to fix your mistakes.
Ed watches your every move, and if you sneak away to have some “bad” food, he catches you at it and screams at you till you cry, sometimes until you throw up.
If you tell people about how badly Ed is hurting you, he threatens to leave you, threatens you that you’ll never find anyone else because you are so worthless, you are nothing without him, and next thing you know you are telling everyone that maybe you were just being too hard on him, or denying it all again. Sometimes you can tell people what Ed is doing to you and they just don’t believe it. They insist you look well and fine, they joke that maybe they need someone like Ed around to help them improve themselves, they tell you a little constructive criticism can be motivating. Unless Ed hurts you so badly you go into the hospital, people just don’t want to believe he can be that bad – he’s such a charming guy.
But mainly you don’t complain about him because you can’t imagine life without Ed. He has made himself the center of your world. If Ed demands you quit seeing a friend, you quit seeing them. If he demands you quit doing something, you quit doing it. After all, before he came along you were just dumpy, ordinary, lazy, clumsy, selfish, but you had such potential, and well he recognized it, and promised you he’d help you become the beautiful woman he could see inside you – just as long as you went along with a few ideas he had for you to improve yourself. No pain, no gain – no beauty comes without a price – right?
One day you wake up and you realize your life is out of control. And maybe you need help to get away from Ed. So you leave, and go to someone for help. But Ed stalks you. You look up and see him when you’re grocery shopping, when you’re at a restaurant. You’re afraid he will come around if you are alone at night, when you are naked and defenseless in the shower. At first maybe he just talks to you. You can try to tell people about it but unless he’s actually physically hurting you they tell you just to ignore him or refuse to talk to him and he’ll go away. But he keeps coming back. Maybe even 5 years later when you think he’s forgotten you cross the street one day and there he is, behind the plate glass window of a store, staring back at you. Letting you know he’s there. Always watching. Always waiting.
June 14, 2009 at 1:10 am
Thank you, for such a thoughtful post *hugs*
Rain :)
June 14, 2009 at 10:33 pm
Wonderful post.
June 15, 2009 at 2:22 pm
Thank you for this post.
Ed is always laying in wait. Always watching. Like a snake in the grass. Once he knows you, knows your weaknesses, he will *always* know you. Constant vigilance. Constant.
June 15, 2009 at 8:11 pm
This is an amazing post, Amananta.
June 18, 2009 at 6:39 am
Thanks, Amananta. Tonight (because my blog entries in the wordpress.com auto-system get linked with Allecto’s in the “blogs about …[woman hating, for example],” I came upon your well-written comments in ‘08 on Allecto’s blog. For the first time from your comments, I understand the inanity of male privilege masquerading as cisgender dialog misdirected against women born as women. Here’s my hope for your strength of intellectual honesty — which you carefully display — to continue as you blog. Sorry to read the situation about your mother, too; your readers are with you.
June 18, 2009 at 6:44 am
Was logged in at wordpress when I wrote the comment above; this is Jude at The Longest War,http://thelongestwar.wordpress.com/
June 20, 2009 at 12:44 am
A friend sent me this. I was just about to pound my body on the treadmill. It gave me pause, and I am in tears. This is so true…. I wish the author would publish the next part… how to get RID of ED!!!!!!!!!
June 21, 2009 at 3:17 pm
Amananta, everything you write is so beautiful and insightful and breathtaking. I honor you.
Also, the post on HAES: dead-on target.
You always see things in a way I’ve never thought of before. Thank you.
June 26, 2009 at 9:18 am
Thanks for spreading awesome in an hellish world. Your posts are incredibly insightful and well-researched, and I quote you in RL.
Much thanks.
July 1, 2009 at 9:20 pm
This is excellent. Thanks, Amanata, for this post (and all of your other posts).
July 7, 2009 at 1:03 am
Dear Amananta:
I didn’t really understand eating disorders until I read this; I had read something about numbers, and was closer, but still distant. Until you.
Off-topic (I hope you don’t mind): I have been enjoying your archives; it is a relief to know it’s not just me, then. I’ve posted things just to maintain a daily-posting streak, but you don’t have any filler. Often, your posts are wonderfully long; a gift. As such, I was shocked and saddened to see you removed Radical Feminism and the Transgendered, or, how to write a post that will infuriate everyone”. That’s a great title; I was looking forward to it. From subsequent posts, I have an idea of what you discussed. As I’ve only read pity and sympathy for transwomen who feel excluded from otherwise women-only spaces, your perspective that women can exclude whom they want and there are larger, farther-reaching exclusions, is unique and its disappearance and the lack of your voice is my loss. It is just a shame that you should be(come) silent.
July 7, 2009 at 2:46 am
Well, I was ruthlessly raked over the coals by the trans community for what was an honest attempt to reach out and build understanding, and was told many things, including that my partner of five years should leave me because I’m toxic and abusive. It’s a funny thing how the vicious smearing of my name (albeit an internet name only) hasn’t done anything to convince me of the wrongness of my ways. Instead I am silent only because they caused me so much real life grief between me and my partner that I no longer feel safe expressing my opinion even under a pseudonym. I feel like everything else I write about, women’s issues, violence against women, etc., which is the focus of practically all of my blog, has been completely ignored – if you google my name the only thing that comes up is a list of vicious smears against me for being “transphobic”. In response to my stating of this, I did see one transactivist sneer that I had nothing else worth talking about anyway.
Needless to say, all of this makes me seriously question the so-called commitment of transactivists to women’s rights.
Even saying this means I will probably get another snarky post aimed at me. All the things I publish about how women are being battered, raped and killed all over the world and it is excuse,d ignored, or approved of by every government, religion, and culture? That’s not important. I imply there might be some actual difference between someone who transitions to being a woman at age 30 and someone who has lived with being female all her life? I’m Satan, stupid, hateful, and write nothing worth reading.
The title of my blog becomes more apt every passing day. Still, I’m glad you enjoyed reading. Sorry for the venting.
August 19, 2009 at 7:16 am
This touched me in a really deep way.
My anorexia/bulimia I always thought was just another side to myself, rather than separate entity to me which made it all the more frustrating.
“Sometimes you can tell people what Ed is doing to you and they just don’t believe it. They insist you look well and fine, they joke that maybe they need someone like Ed around to help them improve themselves, they tell you a little constructive criticism can be motivating. Unless Ed hurts you so badly you go into the hospital, people just don’t want to believe he can be that bad – he’s such a charming guy.”
Oh yeah, this is so incredibly, painfully true.
Either that or people tell you:
Why don’t you just eat?!
And it’s never that fucking simple.
September 2, 2009 at 9:37 pm
You should’t have written bad stuff about “ED” because even though your own story is not a lie, Ed is however a common name in men and you need to realize that because you lack creativity and an open mind, you have put a lot of men in a state of mind where they go outside and introduce themselves to judgemental people like yourself who have one word to google and get a stupid girl’s opinion on who he is. I would seriously rethink about your sorry ass ideas about ED and change your life so that you are no measles scum.
September 2, 2009 at 10:35 pm
You know, ginaovsep@gmail.com, I briefly considered deleting this prize of a stupid comment, but then I decided to leave it up to evermore enshrine your complete, hilarious asininity (not to mention your missing the point by a mile). Grats, idiot. You made my day laughing at your utter stupidity.